The World Health Organization on Monday blasted critics of its investigation into the origins of the Covid-19 pandemic and challenged those claiming to know better to come forward with the smoking gun.
A WHO investigative team is in Wuhan, China — where the first cases were discovered in December 2019 — trying to piece together how the virus jumped from animals to humans before going on to kill more than two million people.
The UN agency’s emergencies director Michael Ryan hit out at those sniping at the mission and said people claiming they have information on how the pandemic broke out should emerge from the shadows.
Ryan said many critics were saying they “won’t accept the report when it comes out”, or that there is “other intelligence available that may show different findings” on how the virus broke out.
“If you have the answers… please let us know,” Ryan told a press conference from the WHO’s headquarters in Geneva.
He asked how responsible it was “to say you won’t accept a report before it’s even written? To say that you have intelligence that has not been provided?”
The WHO mission comes with heavy political baggage — China refused the team access until mid-January and there are question marks over what the experts can hope to find, one year on.
Beijing is keen to put the focus on its recovery from the outbreak. The team toured a propaganda exhibition celebrating China’s recovery from the pandemic in Wuhan on Saturday.
Ryan was responding to a question which referenced new US Secretary of State Antony Blinken, who earlier Monday told NBC that China was falling “far short of the mark”.
“China has to step up and make sure that it is being transparent, that it is providing information and sharing information, that it is giving access to international experts and inspectors,” Blinken said.
“Its failure to do that is a real problem.”
Ryan said the team in the field deserved international support, and in the meantime, “it’s time for people who say and think they have information to start providing it”.
He added that all infectious disease investigations find information that then throws up further questions.
“It’s a detective story,” he said.
– Virology lab visit –
The expert team in Wuhan has now started investigations on the ground, notably visiting the Huanan seafood market where one of the first reported clusters of infections emerged, and the hospital where early patients were treated.
Maria Van Kerkhove, the WHO’s technical lead on Covid-19, said the team would be visiting the Wuhan Institute of Virology.
Former US president Donald Trump pushed an unsubstantiated theory that the virus escaped from the facility.
The team are having “very productive discussions with Chinese counterparts, visiting different hospitals around Wuhan”, Van Kerkhove said.
“They had a very good visit to the market, seeing first-hand the stalls and walking through.”
Van Kerkhove said they had also met with counterparts from the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention.
“They will visit the Institute of Virology. That is being planned,” she added.
Meanwhile WHO director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said it was “encouraging” that the global number of new coronavirus cases had fallen for the third week in a row.
“It shows this virus can be controlled, even with the new variants in circulation,” he said.
However, “we have been here before”, he warned.
“Over the past year, there have been moments in almost all countries when cases declined, and governments opened up too quickly and individuals let down their guard, only for the virus to come roaring back.”